European Erasmus Mundus Master
Sustainable Constructions under natural hazards and catastrophic events 520121-1-2011-1-CZ-ERA MUNDUS-EMMC
1
Reviewer’s form for thesis evaluation
1. Identification of the student
Student: Montenegro Eduarte Juan Sebastian
Thesis: Design of prequalified European beam-to-column connections for moment resistant frames with component based finite element method
Institution: ČVUT v Praze Academic
year:
2016/2018
2. Identification of the reviewer
Name: František Wald
Institution: ČVUT v Praze Position: Prof.
3. Fulfilment of thesis goals
excellent above aver. X average below aver. weak Comments:
The work fulfil all the objectives.
4. Academic/scientific/technical quality
excellent above aver. average X below aver. weak Comments:
The results are valuable. The final sensitivity study should be longer.
5. Formal arrangement of the thesis and level of language
excellent x above aver. average X below aver. weak
European Erasmus Mundus Master
Sustainable Constructions under natural hazards and catastrophic events 520121-1-2011-1-CZ-ERA MUNDUS-EMMC
2
Comments:
The theses are written well.
6. Further comments
The colleague worked very independently on rather difficult task.
7. Grade: C
Use the following scale
A (excellent) B (very good) C (good) D (satisfactory) E (sufficient) F (fail)
In Prague 8 Jan 2018
The Reviewer
________________________
Signature
